
Feeling grumpy? Lumpy? Or fantastically fluffy? All it takes is a little rainstorm to achieve fabulous buffalo freshness!
We read Buffalo Fluffalo, written by Bess Kalb, and illustrated by Erin Kraan (Random House, 2024). Buffalo is big, loud, cantankerous, and cranky…until a passing rain storm reveals that there’s a little buffalo under that brusque exterior. Buffalo Fluffalo was selected for Dolly Parton’s Imagination Library initiative, and was also the story time book we chose to herald in the launch of our Imagination Library tribute exhibit!
You’ll need:
- 1 small box (ours was a 4” x 4” x 4” craft box, but a small tissue box works too!)
- 2 toilet paper tubes
- Construction paper
- “Fresh Buffalo” tree air freshers (template here)
- Scissor, tape, and glue for construction
- Markers for decorating
- Hot glue

Here’s a side view of our buffalo. As you can see, it’s a craft box with toilet paper tube legs (just cut 2 tubes into four pieces). We used mini pie tins for the face, but you can simply add your buffalo’s features on one side of the box. Next, use construction paper to make your buffalo a fluffallo, and don’t forget the grumpy expression!
Once the buffaloes were complete, we invited the story time kids to spread out on the “prairie” with their buffaloes in their laps. Then Katie brought through a rain storm to wash everyone down!

I followed the storm with a basket of classic air freshener trees to hang on each buffalo’s horn. Here’s the template!

Storms can be very scary, but this story time project lets YOU be in charge of the clouds, rain, and lightning!
First, glue a piece of blue construction paper to a corrugated cardboard rectangle (we used 9.75″ x 13.75″
Use a box cutter to cake a window in the second corrugated cardboard rectangle. Then glue or tape 2 strips of poster board to the front of the window (definitely use poster board, construction paper is a little too saggy). Add a pair of optional window curtains. Then flip the front piece over…
Shorten 2 paper towel tubes so they fit inside the sides of the window, then hot glue them firmly in place (we reinforced the connection with tape as well). Hot glue the tubes to the back piece of the theater. Now there is a gap between the front and back of the theater. This is where you drop your stick puppets! We also hot glued a small box to the very back of the theater to keep it more steady (our box was white, sorry, it’s a little hard to see in the photo!).
To make the stick puppets, cut a lightning bolt, fringe of rain, crescent moon, and storm cloud from construction paper, then glue or tape them to the bottom of a jumbo craft stick (ours were 8″ long).
To operate the theater, simply drop the puppets into the gap and narrate the story as storm clouds move in, rain comes, lightning strikes, and the skies finally clear to reveal the moon!









